Subscribe
Logo
Logo
  • Topics Icon Topics
    • AI Icon AI
    • Banking Icon Banking
    • Blockchain/DeFi Icon Blockchain/DeFi
    • Embedded Finance Icon Embedded Finance
    • Fraud/Identity Icon Fraud/Identity
    • Investing Icon Investing
    • Lending Icon Lending
    • Payments Icon Payments
    • Regulation Icon Regulation
    • Startups Icon Startups
  • Podcasts Icon Podcasts
  • Products Icon Products
    • Webinars Icon Webinars
    • White Papers Icon White Papers
  • TechWire Icon TechWire
  • Search
  • Sign in
Reading
Surely CNBC You Can’t Be Serious
ShareTweet
Home
Peer to Peer Lending
Surely CNBC You Can’t Be Serious

Surely CNBC You Can’t Be Serious

Peter Renton·
Peer to Peer Lending
·Mar. 22, 2012·1 min read

CNBC has a reality show called American Greed. I confess I have never watched it but apparently it profiles people who are out to make a quick buck, often at the expense of others and often in illegal ways.

Last night they aired an episode about James Lull, who allegedly ran an investment scam in Hawaii that bilked 50 investors out of millions of dollars. I have no problem with the TV show, but they wrote this article yesterday “Private Lending: High Reward, Higher Risk?” that was essentially a promotion for the show. In this article they also discussed Prosper and p2p lending. You can find a link to this CNBC article on the American Greed website.

Making a Very Dubious Connection

When you read the article it starts off as your standard p2p lending piece about matchmaking borrowers and lenders. There are some quotes from Joseph Toms, the Chief Investment Officer from Prosper.com as well as an official at the Securities and Exchange Commission. But halfway through the article, the focus suddenly switches from p2p lending to the allegedly illegal activity of James Lull. The reporter then switches back to p2p lending, as if the two have similarities.

I found this incredible. To me, this is like doing an article on drug use in baseball and then including a piece about NFL quarterback Peyton Manning (I read somewhere he may have signed with the Broncos :-)). Sure it is all sports but one has very little to do with the other. And the casual reader may be left wondering if Peyton Manning uses performance-enhancing drugs. Of course I am not suggesting that here.

I spoke with Joseph Toms yesterday and he said he was stunned about the implied comparison. He happily agreed to an interview with CNBC – both Prosper and Lending Club do these kinds of interviews all the time – but he had no idea his comments would be used in a promotional piece for American Greed. In fact, as he recalled the depth of conversation he had with the reporter about the steps the company takes to provide full transparency of data, it seemed astonishing to him that an attempt at this connection would be made by such a reputable news organization.

If I was at Prosper I would be hopping mad. Suffice it to say that private lending of hundreds of thousands of dollars for real estate loans has as much in common with Prosper as Jose Canseco has with Peyton Manning.

  • Peter Renton
    Peter Renton

    Peter Renton is the chairman and co-founder of Fintech Nexus, the world’s largest digital media company focused on fintech. Peter has been writing about fintech since 2010 and he is the author and creator of the Fintech One-on-One Podcast, the first and longest-running fintech interview series.

    View all posts
Advertisement
Tags
CNBCProsper
Related

12 Alternatives for LendingClub Investors

Webinars this Week: Roadmap Back to Growth, Every Company is a Fintech and Debt Collections

My Quarterly Marketplace Lending Results – Q1 2020

European Investors Looking to Back US Consumer Loans

Popular posts

Today:

  • Revised-AI-InvoiceAI Faces Skepticism. Startups Say: OK, Pay When it Works Jun. 25, 2025
  • Globe-money-symbolsOPINION: Why Brazil and India are leading the global digital shift through payment innovation Jun. 24, 2025
  • Email-AI-pieceAvatar CEOs Have Entered the Meeting Jun. 18, 2025
  • PayabliFunded: Payments infrastructure co Payabli lands $28M Series B to AI-ify Jun. 20, 2025
  • TechNexus The AI IssueSteal Like an AI? Defining Fair Use & Creativity Jun. 25, 2025
  • Jon StonaTips from Airwallex x McLaren on Making the Best of a Fintech Sponsorship  Jun. 18, 2025
  • GreenliteAI-Alex-WillGreenlite AI is on a mission to revolutionize banking compliance Jun. 10, 2025
  • TechNexus The AI IssueThe AI Paradox Jun. 18, 2025
  • DanMurphy-FN-headshotCFPB’s Next Open Banking Battle Begins Jun. 3, 2025
  • WP UmbrellaTo Bank or Not to Bank: The ILC Question Jun. 5, 2025

This month:

  • WP UmbrellaTo Bank or Not to Bank: The ILC Question Jun. 5, 2025
  • DanMurphy-FN-headshotCFPB’s Next Open Banking Battle Begins Jun. 3, 2025
  • GreenliteAI-Alex-WillGreenlite AI is on a mission to revolutionize banking compliance Jun. 10, 2025
  • Current stablecoin adoptionWhy Banks (and Fintechs) Need to Embrace Stablecoins Today Jun. 12, 2025
  • ai-work-nexusWalkMe Vets Declare War on SaaS Bloat with $10M Seed for Autonomous Agents Jun. 10, 2025
  • SimonWu-CaptionCathay’s Wu: Secondaries now “a structural pillar” for VC liquidity, exits Apr. 3, 2025
  • Finfluencers(1)Tori Dunlap, Humphrey Yang, Taylor Price–Millions Flock to Finfluencers on TikTok, YouTube–and yes, Facebook–Amid Market Chaos May. 27, 2025
  • Ben Hemani, Founding Partner at Bison VenturesThe Risk and Reward of Betting Big on AI’s Next Frontier Jun. 4, 2025
  • Jon StonaTips from Airwallex x McLaren on Making the Best of a Fintech Sponsorship  Jun. 18, 2025
  • Ironclad State of AI ReportThe Economics of AI Trust Jun. 11, 2025

Advertisement
  • About
  • Contact
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
Subscribe
Copyright © 2025 Fintech Nexus
  • Topics
    • AI
    • Banking
    • Blockchain/DeFi
    • Embedded Finance
    • Fraud/Identity
    • Investing
    • Lending
    • Payments
    • Regulation
    • Startups
  • Podcasts
  • Products
    • Webinars
    • White Papers
  • TechWire
  • Contact Us
Start typing to see results or hit ESC to close
lis digital banking USA Lending Club UK
See all results